– Spoiler Review –
Understandably so, this series has focused on some of Rogue One‘s biggest characters, though many of them have had plenty of additional material about them. So it’s nice to see it put Chirrut Îmwe and Baze Malbus front and center, as while they did get a great book already, they’ve not had much else. Like spending time with old friends, Stephanie Phillips’ Rogue One: Chirrut & Baze #1 might not provide big new insight, but it does remind us why they’re favorites.
Writer Stephanie Phillips really captures the bond and friendship Chirrut and Baze share. The opening sequence, them arguing over Chirrut thinking there are three stormtroopers vs Baze only seeing two works so well, I could hear their voices from the film while reading the dialogue. This doesn’t let up, as Phillips maintains a great banter between the two as they discuss sabotaging a kyber crystal mine, in an effort to keep them out of the hands of the Empire. Yet Phillips uses our knowledge of these two characters and her great characterization of them to make points not just about the oppression the Empire brings to the galaxy far, far away, but for our galaxy too. Along the way, their plan hits a snag when a miner’s still around despite planning for their work to happen after a shift is over, and their interactions with him strike a timely chord. The miner’s not convinced when Chirrut first peacefully confronts him, as the two argue over far away wars and how the repercussions always find their way home to the everyday person. It’s only after Chirrut shows how far he’s willing to go when the miner changes his mind, completing the sabotage for them. Their discussions and the miner’s ultimate choice, while a little rushed due to the space of a single issue, feels like a guide to radicalization, of seeing the bigger picture, and not just standing up for yourself or your comforts, but for those around you who might not have the same opportunities or be worse off even than you believe yourself to be. While times are always fraught in some way or another, it’s particularly a worrying time at this moment in our world and this story hopes you’ll think about more than yourself, like Chirrut and Baze always do, when making choices like who you vote for and what you stand for. So while the story might be a little rushed and not necessarily tell us more about the titular characters, it’s point is more than worth the read.
Originally announced with art by Kieran McKeown, who did have previews of art up until recently, Sean Chen took over at some point, with Yen Nitro for colors and Ariana Maher on lettering. While at times Chirrut and Baze look too young and then suddenly more like they do in the film, Chen manages to bring Chirrut’s idealism and Baze’s pragmatism to the forefront. Chirrut’s eyes are wide open, ironically enough, always attuned to what’s around him, seeing it in ways we could only dream of, though there’s a steeliness when he gets serious with the miner, trying to explain the righteousness of their cause. With Baze, his face is more scrunched at all times, like he’s concentrating on what’s in front of him and missing what’s around him, though the way he looks up to Chirrut tells you all you need to know about how much, despite his disagreements, he really cares for the other man. Yen Nitro’s colors for the kyber cave, the soft blue/white illuminating faces, characters, and the surfaces around them, is wonderous and, even though Chirrut can’t see it, how it’s presented makes you believe he can see it almost just as well as readers can. I also really liked how the Imperials in the final page stand out like a sore thumb against a Jedha city market scene, as their greys and whites, while a little dirty, are nothing compared to the menagerie of beings in background and their various shades of clothing. Ariana Maher’s lettering really makes a big moment hit home, as the little “klik” sound FX for the detonator and Baze’s frustration as nothing happens every time he hits it, feels so desperate thanks to how the SFX showcases nothing is happening. That there’s no SFX as he drops the detonator to the ground only makes it feel more final, like a big choice has to be made now that it won’t remotely go off. Also, the sequence of Baze shouting Chirrut’s name, a much bigger than normal word bubble that’s just barely outlining the letters inside, followed by the overabundance and ferocity of the SFX for his gun’s blasting of the big droid that’s attacking them, shows his feelings for his friend with little usage of words.
Here is one other thing:
- Welp, there’s only one issue of the Rogue One celebration series and it’s out later this month: October 28 offers Rogue One – Darth Vader #1 and it sounds like more Vader, so your mileage may vary. In fact, you can get a glimpse at it now with the preview…feels very World War II-esque.
- Really glad we got these moody main covers from David Marquez.
Rogue One: Chirrut & Baze #1 packs in a timely message into a tale that feels like revisiting old friends.
+ Great message and great characterizations
+ Art brings out a lot of what makes these two tick so well as characters and friends
– Feels a little rushed
Ryan is Mynock Manor’s Head Butler. You can follow him and the website on Bluesky.
ROGUE ONE RELATED REVIEWS:
Rogue One 10th Anniversary One-shots: Cassian Andor | Jyn Erso | Saw Gerrera
Andor Reviews – Season Two: Season Premiere “Episode 1 – One Year Later” & “Episode 2 – Sagrona Teema” & “Episode 3 – Harvest” | “Episode 4 – Ever Been to Ghorman?” & “Episode 5 – I Have Friends Everywhere” & “Episode 6 – What a Festive Evening” | “Episode 7 – Messenger” & “Episode 8 – Who Are You?” & “Episode 9 – Welcome to the Rebellion” | Series Finale “Episode 10 – Make It Stop” & “Episode 11 – Who Else Knows?” & “Episode 12 – Jedha, Kyber, Erso” | Season One: Series Premiere “Episodes 1-3” | “Episode 4 – Aldhani” | “Episode 5 – The Axe Forgets” | “Episode 6 – The Eye” | “Episode 7 – Announcement” | “Episode 8 – Narkina 5” | “Episode 9 – Nobody’s Listening!” | “Episode 10 – One Way Out” | “Episode 11 – Daughter of Ferrix” | “Episode 12 – Rix Road”
Film Review: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (by Ryan) | Novel Review: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (by Chris) | Novel Review: Catalyst: A Rogue One Novel (by Ryan) | Young Adult Novel Review: Rebel Rising (by Ryan) | Soundtrack Review: Rogue One: A Star Wars Story (by Elliot) | Young Reader Review: Guardians of the Whills (by Ryan) | Young Reader Review: Rogue One: Rebel Dossier (by Chris) | Reference Book Review: Rogue One: The Ultimate Visual Guide (by Chris) | Comic Review: Cassian and K-2SO Special #1 (by Ryan)

